Interesting point. But I have not researched that far. I have been collecting The Navigator from Nautical Institute from the beggining ( Issue no.1) . Written by the guys who are in the know. Always excellent stuff.
AIS and GPS jamming and spoofing have been on the Forum agenda for a long time with some excellent observations from some participants including links they provided.
Regarding Splash247 article I think as ussual scriblers there create the hype as I find it surprising,that only ships are affected .How about airplanes . Looks these ary flying , departing ,landing on time and nobody gets lost in some Gulag Archipelago somewhere in the heart of Putin’s Russia.
From the article and from the comments section it is evident that the biggest havoc spoofing is causing is among the peep-show addicts who use AIS to track ships for their sometimes nefarious purposes.
LRIT systems will not help them too as SAT Cs generating this data is dependent on auto input from \GPS too although I do not remember exactly if manual input of position is possible or not . Think it should. . And LRIT is not for all smart asses that use traffic tracking aplications ( land or sat based) ..
So if air pilots do not get lost while flying here and there and airlines are not panicking, then may be they are better trained or have systems taking care of shit happening , which I know they have from some people here.
If so my reasoning is, why not better train and why not introduce such airborne systems to ships and make them shipborne and problem will be fixed with all those lunatics crying wolf and bemoaning the the GPS loss, jamming and spoofing hysteria and blaming not only grounding , loss in space but also collisions as well. This is as far as I am concerned some nonsense. From some articles it looks some shipping folks are extatic of aping everything from air indistry . So why not doing the right thing.
I started in 1982 and have gone through all this technical inventions and toys but because of that never have lost touch with the classics thought by such virtuosos and masters in sea craft navigations, scholars like Bowditch and scores of others like him.
I met scores of crews who were so effing lazy , that they did not even know where to find the goddamn user manual/instruction on the bridge shelves, happy with trickle down method of absorbing only what was written in the handover or verbally passed by predecessor.
But one has to justify them sometimes as ECDIS is at least 750 pages and all the other toys are hovering between 300-400 pages , then for startes a dilingent and responsible OOW must read ca 2000-3000 efiing pages to get savvy only because different manufactures have some different crazy idea how to built , program install their toy and user interface with some more or less complicated menu. Horrible.
What I found lacking on all the ships is the so called “ COMMONALITY “ of equipment often quoted by aviation savvy people and familiar with plane cockpits.
In conclusion it looks that nowadays knowing your last position , speed and course and doing something sensible with such data is a rocket science . I read all this and am stunned in desbelief . .