See, I told you this was the real controversy.
You make a good point about my authority. I lack the appropriate credentials because I’m not a history professor. But I did sleep at a Holiday Inn Express last night, so that should be good for something.
Enough about his shirts, let’s discuss Sal Mercogliano’s bona fides. Here is his LinkedIn resume
Sal Mercogliano LinkedIn Profile
So one will undoubtedly see that any sailing experience he has is literally approaching back to 3 decades ago, was not in the commercial sector and he did not earn a senior level certificate (for unknown reason because if he did sail as a 2nd mate so he should have qualified for a chief mate’s license). Everything else on his CV has no value at all regarding this discussion. Guest lecturer at a small cruise line, teaching online courses for KP (which I did not know they offered) and then becoming a professor of history at a rather small unknown private Christian University in rural NC.
I’ve mentioned previously, if the man had the right stuff in the brainpan as a PhD. he would be a professor at a Federal or State Academy or at the Naval War College or the Naval Postgraduate School. One must imagine that Campbell University has no maritime studies so any courses Mercogliano teaches are general history and nothing more. The inferred evidence is that he simply is not such a bright bulb yet he figured out that with a YouTube channel suddenly he would become the goto guy for media and his scheme worked! Give him credit for that but his bona fides still appear to be printed on toilet paper.
Addendum: is also should be pointed out that under the licenses and certificates section of his LinkedIn profile all Mercagliano lists is North Carolina Firefighter Level I/II with no mention of his even still having his USCG license. Why is that I must ask?
Why? Because he’s rather live in a serene area of North Carolina instead of in NYC?
You think very highly of the academies. Academia does not agree with your assessment.
We’re a think tank now? When can I start collecting speaking fees at the local bar where I dispense my maritime knowledge? Why aren’t I getting paid for my opinion pieces?
I think the academy instructors would have more valuable input on something like this. Maritime history? Probably not. But all my instructors had at least a masters license (except one guy who taught RADAR and left after a year or two to keep sailing), most sailed as master or at least CM, and sailed more recently than Sal. Sal just happens to have a YouTube channel.
True.
Also true.
I’m not arguing that he should have been interviewed, reporters should have gone to academy professors. Who knows? Maybe they did and the professor(s) they asked had enough sense not to speculate on the record about what might have happened.
Saw CNN had Captain McManus from SUNY on - they were one question into the interview when they had to cut away for a live press conferance - they also had him on the simulator at SUNY running the simulation - but he was very politically correct - stuck to simple facts and no speculation. Maybe that is why the media doesn’t really want to talk to responsible professionals - they are boring - more “entertaining” to have someone spurt out a bunch of guesses
Ask Dr.Sal how to do it.
But I am not a harsh critic of Dr.Sal.
I have just dropped a raw meet on the table hoping others can cook it.
I had high expectations, when his channel appeared, quite happy there was someone who wiould be a counterweight to all the BS served by the media and their scribblers.
He has fallen into a trap of ETTO ( efficiency thoroughness trade off) and the "research " he promised did not materialise on many occasions.
And I am sure He knows what the research means having Msc and Phd under his belt . Had to make two dissertations to have such academic titles. Simple as that.
And I am pretty sure he does not give a hoot about some guys exposing his fopaux as He got an adulating crowd of cheering ignorants happy to listen to his material and pay for that . 200K + .
It is a good crowd to have Your channel monetized . If this is His business plan i am fine with it but I naively thought once He was after something else.
Scuttlebutt S03 E01 Sal Mercogliano On Shipping Part 1 (youtube.com)
I think we have three types of experts who provide their commentary to the media. The first type are those who are well versed and knowledgeable in the subject they are providing opinion on and usually they will ensure to say where they might not have all the knowledge to comment. The second are those who know they don’t know but so love being recognized that they just don’t care that they are often inaccurate in their statements and lastly there are those who believe in their own mind that somehow they are an expert and that what they say has to be accurate in all respects. I believe Sal Mercagliano falls into this last category.
Based on what? Your/Society’s interpretation of what the correct career path is for everyone? What if he just likes rural North Carolina? What if he just enjoys the slower pace of life? There are an infinite number of reasons that someone makes the career decisions they do and upward “progress” is not always a part of it.
He is also the department chair.
Say what you want about Sal he was in the right place at the right time and one of the only ones in his particular space that was able to be quickly found by the media when they needed someone. Good for him.
The world’s media needed an expert …
I’m gonna call BS on his just being Mr. Happy Camper there in Buies and that if offered a position at one of the schools I listed would be gone so fast from Campbell U that there’d be burnout tracks all the way out of town (which obviously wouldn’t be very long)…
I have only one Hawaiian Shirt.
Its a genuine as worn by the Original Tom Selleck in Magnum PI.
Not sure about the Pockets.
If you cant get a Magnum PI Hawaiian Shirt, Hawaii 5 O will do in a pinch. I think The Original Steve Margaret was more of a Suit Guy
I had a mustache but my sister said I looked like Freddie Mercury not Tom Selleck so it had to go.
There’s no need to speculate. Most people who watch these videos etc have almost no understanding as to what happened. Just having the basic facts explained is helpful for most people.
Everyone wants to know “why” it crashed, in other words “why” the blackout happened. The only way to answer that is to speculate as to possibilities.
That doesn’t make for interesting reporting. It’s factual reporting but not interesting reporting.
One could say something along the lines of the blackout was likely caused by some kind of failure with ship’s generators. Won’t know for sure until we have more information. That’s a reasonable inference, not mere speculation.
Then the setup of the redundant SSDG and EDG and switchboards could be explained.
I am a bit shocked why there is such an anguish here that Dr.Sal , whom I still greatly admire , despite his obvious little departures from facts , has been "analysed " or debunked or fact checked.
Viewers here are strongly encouraged to examine all his videos to find some, when He himself is debunking others.
Eeven in his latest, he questions Corps of Engineers video providing his owm opinion. I am not 100% sure but in his collection of video clips there is one where Dr.Sal does not speak very highly even about his buddy CEO John K. with whom he seems so chummy chummy on several other videos.
Viewers are also strongly encouraged to examine gCaptain Forum stats and draw their own conclusions , how many does not give a hoot abt Dr.Sal debunking with only few braves ,self proclaimed solicitors who with passion try to defend him completely ignoring presented evidence.
I am quite certain , that Dr.Sal , with his supreme elloquence and gift of gab and general knowledge of shipping issues, can defend himself and would eat blokes like me for breakfast in direct verbal confrontation.
He simply does not give a hoot abt it , as any time there will be a call from CNN or other news joint ,asking him for comment . So He has not time to engage some criticks as it is not worth his effort.
But I am sure this community here, can exert some pressure through gCaptain for example . , to remind His excellency The Professor , that not only crowds of ignorants are viewing Him .
So may be He can walk the talk and include more research into his material to gain more credibility among old salts as the PROFESOR should sound " PROFESORIAL" .and provide more quality instead of hastily prepared quantity.
I am sorry but from people with Msc and Phd under their belt I am expecting more then from chirping various forum dwellers .
.Unless He does not care , then I rest my case.
Makes me wonder if the last is on topic or off topic ??? Beats me
I think Michael Creighton (sp) is really onto something there.
It bugs me a little that the early news reports mention the PSC deficiencies without context. The reporting of hitting the pier and one defective gauge on the Dali just muddy the waters for most readers. Sal fixes that here.
Here’s a Baltimore Sun article that provides the correct perspective on those deficiencies.
Over its seafaring life, the Cezanne has been cited for many more “deficiencies” than the Dali during port inspections, but neither ship had one so significant that it was prevented from sailing.
“I don’t think there’s any red flags there at all,” former merchant mariner Sal Mercogliano, who reviewed the ships’ inspection histories, told The Baltimore Sun. “Ships will get caught for typically minor infractions.”
People can nitpick his videos all day long if they like but he’s correct here, provides the needed perspective and has the credibility with the media to get the call.
If Sal was working on his video until they were perfect almost nobody would have heard of him.
Thank You for keeping this thread going and providing yet anothe evidence ( unfortunately) , that Dr.Sal comprehension regarding certain issues is to put it mildly “very shallow” .
One must distinguish between two processes that will be applicable here in case of M/V Dali.
- The investigation by competent body -in this case NTSB , and establishing the root causes of the accident without apportioning of the blame as per following declaration written on the face of every accident report.
Remark as above is on every Flag State investigation report .
Hence for the purpose of NTSB investigation previous alleged incidents/events are IRRELEVANT.
- Litigation where blame will be apportioned and/or established . And in this case ALL will be taken into account and ALL will be nitpicked by contesting parties.
The SMS of the Company will be Xrayed , seen through microskopic lenses , the honorable brethren of Judges and EXPERTS and witness experts will focus on literally everything and they will dig deep in the history to establish what was company safety culture, regarding for example ISM code., reporting defficiencies, internal audits , nonconformities, maintenance , PMS - THE WHOLE SHEBANG .
As ISM code may be one’s great ally when applied properly and not for PR causes but for safety or THE LAST NAIL TO YOUR COFFIN .
Do You know Dear Capt who said that ??? - do some research pls . Give You a tip - the world wide recognised expert on ISM code and it’s application. And pls read some of his works before jumping into the role of Dr.Sal solicitor. Please!!!
Well , there are no red flags for amateur Dr. Salvatore but there will be many!!! for the Honorable Judges sitting on the case.
Unless of course the case will be settled in otherway. But this other way will also include throwing arguments at each other by minds mych bigger then yours, mine or Dr.Salvatore
Do You want to bet. ???
On this You are absolutely right but there are many ways of saying things about which one knows NOTHING or very little without stepping on the land mine , thus loosing credibility.
Cheers
