Thank you all for the thanks but I do need to share the credit. So here’s a bit of history:
The truth is this forum was up for over a year with me pretty much talking to myself because I deleted anything I felt was inappropriate. Then a few guys started asking serious questions and got serious answers void of all humor. So instead of talking to myself we had a handful of guy… but, mostly, no one stuck around.
One of those handful was Capt. Lee who spent hours each week researching sources to write thoughtful answers to difficult questions.
He was captain of a large workboat and came to gcaptain because our competitor at the time, a maritime forum that was plagued with political bickering, racial comments and mean spirited attacks and Lee just wanted to share helpfull advice.
At the time Lee worked 12 hour shifts alongside another captain, Anchorman. Well it wasn’t long before this relief found out about Lee’s long list of posts and soon Anchorman started waiting until Lee fell asleep at night then he’d logging into gcaptain for the sole purpose of poking fun at Lee’s comments, blowing holes in his theories and giving him a rash of sh!t.
My first reaction was “who the F is this guys giving our best contributor a hard time!?” and I eanted to delete this guy and ban him from the forum but there were a few problems. First his posts were F’n funny as hell! Some of funniest stuff I’d ever read in my life and second most of what he said - at least the stuff between the hijinks- was spot on and pertinent to the conversation. His posts weren’t just funny but contained smart and valuable advice!
So I could have banned him but I would gave lost both entertainment and valuable information so I hesitated.
At this point I wasn’t logging in each night just to check up on the site and diligently moderate posts … now I was glued to my computer clicking refresh every 5 minutes eagerly waiting Anchorman’s next post! But I did feel bad because Anchorman was laying it on Lee thick and Lee was our best, most helpful, member. I would have done nearly anything to defend him if he was attacked by the press, laid off from work or harassed by the coast guard (I still would!)
So I asked Lee if he wanted Anchorman banned and he basically laughed at me saying something along the lines of “You think I can’t handle my own relief!?”
What ensued was pure comedy gold. Lee started shoveling derogatory statements back to Anchorman… remarks smarter and funnier than he ever received back. Did Anchorman give up, loose his cool or lay off Lee. Hell no, instead he began upping his fame. What ensued was a comedy arms race with bigger bangs than a russian nuke explosion!
Then I started getting calls from friends saying things like “Who are these guys, they have all the DPO’s on the ship glued to the computer and in stiches” and “We almost had a drive off today because the engineers were all up in dpo laughing about some forum post.” Soon these guys started logging in to join the discussion.
Mariners, lots and lots of them, started logging on and the forum took off.
But the best part was not the humor itself, it was the fact that here were two really smart guys with very different opinions on running a ship, instead avoiding each-other and complaining to the crews about the shit the other guy was doing… Instead of hating each other (as so often happens when to smart, experienced captains are put on one ship) these guys were best friends! They worked off each orher’s strengths and used humor to smooth out there differences!
Sure, I was Chief Mate on Transocean’s biggest/newest badass drillshup with my choice of command or transfer to the first of Transocean’s newbuilds and they were on a much smaller workboat but… they showed me how ships should operate and kinda made me want to leave and join their crew.
Well many years have past and while they still sling danm funny remarks at each other… one is now captain of his own big bad drillship and the other is among the industry’s most respected Chief Mates and on the short list for command… and If they ever join the same ship as Captain, I’ll be the first to volunteer as their chief mate.
P.S. There is another, related, reason I stopped actively moderating the discussion. When these guys started getting on a roll the sign-up rate and number of new messages started skyrocketing. I started having trouble just reading all the posts and deleting spam let alone decide if each one is appropriate or not. And how could I let Lee and Anchorman get away with with their comments without allowing new members a chance to prove there was wisdom and experience behind their humor? How would I have know c.captain or sweat and grease had decades of hard won experience and an eagerness to share their wisdom if I had banned them after the first inappropriate post?
Back to the history, as the forum started rocketing in popularity I began to get bogged down in major technical problems. The high visitor count combined with hundreds clicking refresh every ten seconds to read Lee’s latest remark… started causing server crashes and attracted spam bots. So I became to busy to moderate every post.
And a few months later, when things settled down, I set up moderator accounts to enable a few select members help moderate posts. But who do you pick for this job? Most forums pick their top members so I offered the gig to anchorman, Lee and a few others. And rhe basic response was something along the lines of: "You want me to play HR and babysit new recruits? We are all adults here and none of us want that. Believe me, if someone steps out of line, lies or gives another member too much grief then we’ll have no problem calling bullshit. Just keep the spam and politics iff the board and we’ll be fine. "
So thats why we have no moderators. We are all adults, all know the basic rules and we can all report any post we like for further review… and we have NO shortage of guys willing to call bullshit!