Cheating on the USCG Unlimited Masters Exam

Personally I find it harder to create ways to cheat on the exam than it is to just learn the material. Even more so if you’re an academy grad. Between Lapware, UpgradeU,Capt. Joe, AND an entire License Seminar class, there really is not an excuse to not know what’s on the test. They quite literally have all the questions, answers, and worked out solutions. Rules and Chart plot should be a cake walk considering there’s a very small number of questions. There’s what? 8 or 9 plots? If you do 2 a day the week before your test you will have seen every single one. Failing stab and TNav/Cnav make the most sense to me just because there’s always room for error in math problems and there’s always the common wrong answers in the multiple choice box. But again, limited number of questions so if you spend more than 2 or 3 weeks studying you’ll have have seen the questions before.

Everyone has been saying for years that the question bank is changing and that Lapware will be useless soon, yet no one has ever seen new questions. A few years ago one of my instructors went down to WV to help audit the questions on the test and explained the archaic way of how difficult it is to get rid of questions that are no longer relevant. Based on the experience he had I would say it will be a long while before the question bank changes dramatically.

As for the original question posed, sure, people cheat. Specially for 2nd/3rd’s license tests. I know of people who have done it both in the academy setting and at REC’s. But like I said, I wouldn’t find it worth the risk and would rather just be confident in myself knowing I can pass the damn thing.

Having just passed the C/M Unlimited Exam, I can maybe provide a little insight into this. I learned a lot form my 3rd Mate examinations, specifically on what to do and not to do, in order to achieve a passing score.

I found that the Houston Marine calculator method is much more simple and precise than your traditional work down and the formula is in Bowditch II. I definitely got a sideways glance from the Charleston REC when I finished Celestial in under an hour. They even checked my work, but that method is legit. Pub 229 is just a series of calculations of that same formula, and calculating the contents of Pub 229 helped keep some mathematicians employed during the depression.
There are those people who study and memorize answers, that definitely happens, but as said above if you devote that energy into actually learning the material you will probably have a better passing score and a firmer grasp of the concepts.

I was watched like a hawk during my exams, but there were also words of praise and encouragement after each passing score. The REC’s do a great job keeping a professional and positive testing atmosphere while ensuring that the Mariner is carrying out his/her testing schemes legitimately.

The fact that there are more than several incompetent management level mariners is not surprising though. A person may not be able to grasp a concept, but if they work a problem’s solution enough they can memorize where to get information and in what part of the formula it goes. is that mariner able to derive the right answer? sure. Do they actually know the material, and why that number goes in that particular spot for a particular problem? No.

I do not believe that a large amount of cheating goes on at the REC’s, but I do think that a large amount of loopholes exist when it comes to acquiring higher tonnage, management level licenses.

I don’t know they even still teach the 229 method. It makes sense to learn it as a backup but using formulas and an Air Almanac is a lot better.

I believe a major reason for this is we don’t put history into proper context. 229 and bowditch tabels were created because we didn’t have scientific calculators back then. The tables served to speed up the plot. Now doing anything but the slowest way possible is frowned on.

When I was doing assesments I never followed the rules. I made each 2/m do a plot without 229, I also made them do a day’s work backwards, and they always had the same complaint “no fair, that’s cheating”.

But is it? Maybe inside an REC it is but in the real world you need to cconstantly be looking for ways to reduce work, improve accuracy/consistency, and increase speed. That’s what professional development is all about but somehow that has gotten lost in the USCG’s strict training requirements.

Pub. 229 is in the exam room and Pub. 249 is not.

I taught myself using the Starpath books and that was a mistake. It’s a better way to navigate but not a better way to pass the exam. The Practical Navigator guy does a good job of blending exam passing and day to day use of celestial.

I am aware of this but I was discussing signing off shipboard evaluations. Maybe I am wrong (many of my mates thought so) I did not feel it was my job as chief me too help them pass the examination, rather, imho it was my job to make sure they have the practical skills they needed.

That brings us to another form of “cheating”. I constantly got the pushback that “everyone else’s chief made in captains to sign off he’s a valuations. Just saying this and I’ll be out of your hair.”

Unfortunately for them I enjoy teaching but I certainly understand the appeal of gundecking eval‘s. Especially celestial evaluations on a drillship.

It’s not worth risking your career over…Im a hawsepiper, I studied for a year and during that time and testing for my 3rd was one of the more stressful times of my life.
While the generals can be memorized with enough study time these modules contain 1500-3000 question possibilities EACH…can’t remember exactly but the bank was extensive.
But beyond that, you have to know how to plot a chart to pass Chart Plotting, miss one question and you miss the next two because they’re connected.
You have to know how to do your Nav Problems, but once you know how to tackle one “type” of question such as a set and drift, or an amplitude you have the answer to 150-200 potential variations of that same problem and it makes it so much easier. I do my azimuths the long hand (pub) version so the only formula I really memorized was SinD/CosL…no cheating necessary.
If the REC we’re doing their job, they would monitor cameras and thoroughly analyze the scalp paper we are required to turn in.
Maybe you get lucky (1 in 150-200 chance) and you get the exact Plotting test you had studied the night before, but those chances are slim.

So this entire thread was brought up because of the perceived incompetence of several higher level Mariners. What deems them incompetent? Is it their knowledge base? Or, what I am suspecting, is that it could be a failure to stay abreast and trained up on ever changing and evolving technologies and the ways that we interact with people.

A Master Mariner could have all the knowledge in the world but may not be able to use an ECDIS or use Excel to fill out the office’s required reports. I’m sure there are many more examples of technological illiteracy that people have encountered throughout the industry. Does this make the person a bad Mariner? No. Does it look bad in the eyes of the company and incompetent? Yes.

Passing the Chief Mate exam did not prepare me to take the reigns as the CM or Master of a vessel except in one very important and critical area, Stability. Besides that, the test did basically nothing to prepare me for the extra responsibility. It is merely a stepping stone. It just separates those who are willing to work for it, and those who are not.

What needs to happen is there should be actual management training courses and exams. We have evolved in the way we do things on vessels and our training should reflect this. I bet there are many Mariners reading this thread right now that wish their Chief Mate or Captain had some actual management training. Many Masters are great Mariners but bad Managers, thus being deemed incompetent or possibly, as this thread suggests, of fraudulent qualifications.

A Masters or Chief’s ticket in todays world, should come with finance, accounting, EQ, HR and Project Management training.

None of the above. They have always been those people in our ranks but most Mariners are smart enough and adaptable enough to keep out of trouble most the time.

The new problem that my source is worried about is very specific: individuals with a low iq

That is some seriously anecdotal and subjective evidence, John…

One guy said that there are dummies with master’s licenses…:face_with_raised_eyebrow:

To be fair, I have sailed with quite a few licensed engineers that didn’t seem to know the basics.

Mine did way back when. It was known as “Ship’s Business and Legal Knowledge”. When I did a refresher course we were required to construct a basic stability program in Excel for a ship. I had previously done one in Lotus 123. When I got my ticket I ditched the log tables, consigned the slide rule to my workshop and did all my nav on a HP calculator. I had programs for Mercator sailing, intermediate points on a great circle, and a sight program.

Ive always wondered how some of the guys I worked with passed their c-nav and flashing light to get their oceans license. These are guys who could barely make a coherent log book entry.

In one ship the Ch.Engineer had purchased an Apple knock-off in Taiwan while standing by the vessel. He got some stick from the office as the office could not see what use a desktop computer could be onboard a ship. Now all you people can blame me. We worked our arses off to show its relevance. I was chief mate at the time and all the counterfeit programs were on 5 inch floppy disks.
We catalogued the engine and ship’s spares, constructed a basic stability program and maintenance schedule and submitted well typed reports to the office. A critical path analysis of a forthcoming dry dock that was, in time honoured fashion, ignored was $60 under what one class item cost and the yard was 50% under. The office wasn’t within a country mile.
The word processing program was a revelation considering the typewriters we had at the time. I said to one branch manager that he was lucky the typewriter I was using wasn’t in the office. When he asked for clarification I replied that if it was one of his typists would have picked it up and thrown it out the window where it may have killed someone.

Well that’s why I posted it here and not as an article on the homepage. And that’s why i’m not naming any names.

And it wasn’t just “some guy” it was an operations manager who has been hiring masters for decades.

It took him decades? Every year that passes I see many of the same problems from years previous & new Masters make the same mistakes over & over. I bet Masters today are just as dumb as they always been but your operation manager friend was too dumb in his younger years to notice it. Ask any old Chief Engineer did they work with any low IQ Masters 20 years ago & we’ll talk your ear off with sea stories. We’ve known all along what your friend is just figuring out.

True but these things come in waves and the key to preventing chaos is to keep the peaks from getting to high.

This forum is not a good place for making policy decisions or for spelling out absolutes but it does a fairly good job at gauging perceptions throughout the industry.

That was the real purpose of this thread. Not to point fingers or anything… just to get a better feel for your thoughts on this observation.

My thoughts & observations: I started my maritime career in 1996. Back then I thought every Master, CE & most other people were pretty smart fellas. As time passed I could pick out flaws a lot easier. I don’t think other people became dumber. I just got older & wiser. Thats probably what’s going on with the old ops manager, nothing to do with cheating or easier USCG exams.

They don’t call 'em grumpy old men for nothing.

I am of the opinion prospective engineering graduates of maritime academies should not only pass the 3AE exam but also the FE [ EIT] exam as a prerequisite to graduation. It would be of value to the maritime industry and the graduate. Otherwise I see no reason for someone to spend 4 years of time and money in a maritime academy to gain the same knowledge that could be obtained in a 2 year technical school concentrating on practical marine mechanical subjects. Unfortunately there doesn’t seem to be schools of this nature in the US.

In Indonesia you can leave college and get a job as the Master, no other step necessary…
Had one on a course once, he was maybe just 30, all the other students worshipping him when he told us what vessel he was master on, huge pipelayer ( then I knew he was just the at the dock Captain) pulled up the UTM slides which has Asia in the middle, but no country names, he was unable to find Singapore on the map…all the other students laughing ( all 2nd and 3rd mates)