One book out of the24 in the REC? Even if you marked that book to be readily identifiable and you could pick which you wanted, what if someone else got that book first? Probably better to just learn the material.
I wonder what % of people cheat to bring in formulas that are right there in Bowditch.
If you show up early and you have a pretty good chance of getting the right book. If not you fail and try again on the retake.
My point is it’s difficult to cheat on your own but easy if you work as a group and each tackle one piece of the work.
The testing requirements for a USCG engineering license are already abysmally low, hopefully things have changed. When I was sailing there were study guides which were basically all the questions and answers provided by the USCG under the FOI [freedom of information act]. No oral exam and the math required was high school level at best. If one had to cheat to pass it is a sad statement as to the qualifications of US mariners.
Personally, when the oi boom was going on I knew guys who had a USCG Chief license who applied to companies from the EU. These companies required a preemployment test which could be done online. It was a simple test; gear ratios, torque etc. but most could not pass it. All were graduates of various maritime academies. Their explanation? “I forgot all that since school I just spin wrenches”. I helped some pass their online test but felt a bit guilty as I knew they would be discovered later to be little more than oilers with a license.
I don’t know anything about the engineering exams except this:
License exams are one of the top ten topics of conversation among deckies. Specially the younger guys are always sharing tips and worrying about exams and changes the NMC may or may not make.
And at the Academies the deckies are always stressed about license.
And on this forum there are a ton of threads about the deck license.
But very rarely in my career have I ever hear an engineer worrying about exams. 
Give me 6 weeks and I’ll pass the 3 a/e test.
A bold statement, but can you do the actual work required of a legitimate 3rd asst with experience.? No easy feat after just passing a paper test and not getting a bit of grease on your clothes and skinning a few knuckles.
Nope.
But isn’t that the point of this discussion? You don’t have to be a genius.
Goodness, you must be really smart.
John, the point I was making is the engineering exam in the USA is much easier than it is is in many other countries. Multiple choice, no oral exam in the USA? In the UK and other developed countries the requirements are much higher. The deck exam? I have no clue.
A board type exam would certainly make licenses mean more, but who’s going to fill those spots? As @jdcavo regularly points out for all our bitching the jobs stay open at NMC.
If the USA didnt want cheating in exams, they would be verbal like the UK.
Multiple choice is to get everyone to pass…
The thought of verbal USCG tests pisses me off. I’m glad the USCG gives multiple choice exams & not verbal ones where examiners can ask anything they want & get to be judge & jury. If they did, the New York REC would only pass pro-union New Yorker candidates, the Lousiana REC would only pass Cajun candidates, Kings Pointers examiners would give a pass to everyone wearing the same ring as them & fail everyone else. If females & African Americans thought they had it bad a few decades ago imagine how it would have been with popularity contest USCG verbal tests? I don’t trust humans, we’re terrible creatures. Multiple choice tests where every test is exactly the same for everyone without an examiner judging a person on their stutter, nervousness, accent, demographics etc. is the only American way to go.
I find it hard to disagree with you Pebble on some points. I never cheated, but tested in Baltimore, Miami, and New Orleans at various times. Most were multiple choice, thank goodness. The last few tests were drawing pilotage, memorization… you bet your ass. Was still up to the examiner if your drawing was right. I never felt bias except for long hair, but those were multiple choice questions way back when at that particular exam site… Not a problem for me, I studied… However, once I cut it, got better seats on the airplane.
I always try to be fair & level headed. But honestly I must admit I probably have a slight bias against people who have a bunch of tattoos on their arms, hands, necks & face. If I was an examiner & 2 candidates were borderline passing a verbal test, one was clean cut & the other tattoo’ed I hope I would treat both fairly but I know there’s a lot of people out there who don’t give a rat’s ass about being fair. People are biased, screw verbal tests.
Why only Verbal and Multiple Choice Exams as options??
What about written tests, either on paper or using computer?
Nautical exams per STCW standard are now done this way. No verbal or M.C. Exams.
My experience with M-C exams are limited to Petty Officer course in the Navy where the tester used a template with holes cut in it to check that the correct boxes were ticked. (He did check that only one box was ticked for each question)
One guy that was very good at remembering patterns was always waiting to the end of the allotted time to deliver his answers.
When the tester raised his template to check a delivered answer sheet he memorized the pattern and ticked the corresponding boxes.
He was not “top of the class”, but managed to pass.
My other experience with M.C. exams were, taking a Correspondence course in Basic Drilling Technology from University of Texas, Austin and a Well Control course held by VETCO in Singapore . (No memorable events)
It took me 6 months of self study to go from 1600 Master to 3rd unlimited.
I worked with a 2nd Mate unlimited who couldnt figure out a simple Speed, time and distance calculation. Every time I asked him a basic question his same answer was… “oh I forgot.” A few months later I overheard him talking about how easy the exam was because his uncle was one of the civilian examiners at the REC N.O.
Fast forward it took me 2 years of self study to get my Master Unlimited.
A few months later this same 2nd, is telling me how he is planning to “go get the Master Unlimited next week” when he gets off the boat. When I asked if he had been studying he said no, that he was gonna study over the weekend then go get it.
That last conversation was about 5 years ago. I have not sailed with him since but I know of at least one person who cheated his way to a license, but there is no way to prove it.
Written tests are a better way to test a candidates level of knowledge and understanding of a subject. Questions are posed in the form “Calculate the …” .
With multiple choice type questions with say five possible answers a, b, c, d, e. you have a 20 % chance of ticking the right box even if you know nothing about the subject. If you have studied and you know you can eliminate say a, b, and c then you have a 50% chance of ticking the right box. This is hardly a good test of a candidates knowledge because of the chance of “fluking” the question. If he has to answer a question by calculation then it really tests his knowledge and understanding.
Oral tests were usually three to five days after finishing all the written papers. This gave the examiner time to check and mark all the papers. The oral was based on your experience and standard topics like drydocking, fire-fighting on board, groundings, report writing etc. Plus he would also discuss your written papers and if in the engineering papers you had made a mistake in the answer, then you better have it corrected in your mind before the oral. It could be the difference between passing and failing. The oral exam was usually between one and two hours depending on what the examiner thought of you and how you went with the written papers. Most examiners I had were fair but I did have some heated arguments on some topics that I felt I was more knowledgable on. Sometimes this was the ploy they would use to see if you really believed in yourself. As regards previous comments on do Engineers worry before exams. I certainly did because there was a lot riding on the result.
The US is not the top of the food chain when it comes to quality mariners, regardless of cheating or not. The system is broken.