I want to ask a question regarding the reality of union line handlers, and I’m hoping to get perspectives from people on both the vessel and shoreside sides of the industry.
I have worked in and out of all sorts of port and terminal arrangements. Some work better than others. (Looking at you IMTT)
To be clear, I’m not anti-union, and I’m not trying to take work away from anyone. I’m all for people getting paid and making as much money as possible. My question is more about the operational and safety realities of the situation.
What frustrates me is that there have been times when a vessel and its crew gets put in a bad position because line handlers fail to show up, arrive late, or are otherwise unavailable. In some of those situations, the ship’s crew could have safely put the lines out themselves and completed the operation.
So my questions are:
- What are the actual repercussions if a vessel puts out its own lines when line handlers don’t show up?
- Are there true legal or regulatory consequences, or is it mainly a labor grievance issue?
- Has anyone here experienced a situation where a vessel bypassed the line handlers and handled its own lines? What happened afterward?
- What is stopping companies from using other labor especially in justifiable circumstance?
I’m genuinely trying to understand the practical reasons behind the system. From a mariner’s perspective, it sometimes feels like a work rule is being prioritized over operational efficiency and safety. Which it totally against what all of these companies preach.
Looking forward to hearing everyone’s experiences and opinions.
FYI: I ran this through AI in order to better protect my anonymity as I tend to have an identifiable writing style.