"Total" Compensation

[I][QUOTE=Capt. Lee;101037]"That is funny you would mention that. I had heard that many letters of experience were falsified in order to comply with contractual experience in position requirements. It is something that we refused to do. What we ended up doing was using a third party assessor to assess all contractual positions. They must have worked all that out though, because the people that I know over there are experienced professionals.

Having a person on the crew that is not cutting the mustard is frustrating and will only be tolerated for so long before enough is enough. Like you said, you may like these guys as people, but certain positions are more critical than others. It is a fine line, because we spend over half our lives with these men and women. It is only human to have personal feelings for these guys. Sometimes to the point of family. I can tell you that 99% of the people I work with I would invite them into my home around my family. It can make a tough decision even tougher sometimes. I have genuinely liked someone that was just terrible at his job. We often have very little control over who is sent to fill a position and most of the time you have to make do with what you have. Having the developmental skills to motivate people to achieve things that themselves or others may not think possible. That is key. What you can achieve as a team is much more than any individual can on his own. With support, training and leadership everything is possible. I have taken someone that I was told just could not do a particular task and in the end they were masters at it. I wish someone would do that to me. I have a hard time accepting that an individual is not capable of something."QUOTE][/I]

And where this comes into play is typically during the ship building phase. Most of us who have been there know that during this time you get really close with the entire crew. However, you really don’t know how the people can perform at their job. This would probably be the negative about shipyard and the hard part once operations begin. You want so bad all of the guys you were with in shipyard succeed and do well, but sometimes that just doesn’t happen, and its hard to make the decision once something happens or appraisal period comes to let the person go or have to write them up for some failure or incompetency’s.

This is a little off topic and I want to make a technical point not a political one. Mention was made as to the difficulty of firing incompetent people if you are friendly with them. This is much less a problem with the unlicensed union guys. Firing hurts them some but they can still go to the hall and ship out. You’re not throwing somebody and their family out on the street. If I have crew that is not competent I get rid of them. Why make the rest of the crew take the weight when there is someone in the hall that wants to do the job right? I don’t feel sorry for the guy on the boat who can’t or wouldn’t do their jobs when there is someone sitting in the hall who can and will. The people to worry about are the rest of the crew.

[QUOTE=Kennebec Captain;101089]This is a little off topic and I want to make a technical point not a political one. Mention was made as to the difficulty of firing incompetent people if you are friendly with them. This is much less a problem with the unlicensed union guys. Firing hurts them some but they can still go to the hall and ship out. You’re not throwing somebody and their family out on the street. If I have crew that is not competent I get rid of them. Why make the rest of the crew take the weight when there is someone in the hall that wants to do the job right? I don’t feel sorry for the guy on the boat who can’t or wouldn’t do their jobs when there is someone sitting in the hall who can and will. The people to worry about are the rest of the crew.[/QUOTE]

You see I agree and disagree with this at the same time. This was my old way of thinking and it is hard for me to shake. There have been several examples in my career where I was wrong about running someone off. I only realized this because either it was not my decision to make or my boss told me to deal with it. Either way I would have never known the individuals potential if I had just run the guy off. Then again, I have been absolutely right about a few guys and have no regrets. One case in particular I wrote a guy up and he wound up getting moved from the vessel. As far as I was concerned he quit. Then my boss fired him and he was thrown out of his office. The guy ended up going to HR and because of how I handled it and how my boss handled it, they moved him to another vessel. My boss contacted me an counseled me (chewed my A$$ out). I was adamant that this was not a good decision in this case. Eventually this person was fired from the company, but not before he did 100’s of thousands of dollars in damage and loss of company reputation.

Today where I am with this is I put it back on the employee. This is very effective. If someone is not meeting expectations you must immediately let them know a particular behavior is not acceptable and make it crystal clear what the expectations are. Give them a timeline and clear goals to meet in this amount of time. Document it and if necessary follow up with a performance appraisal. If an employee fails to meet these clear expectations then it is their own fault. I believe in being as fair as possible and managing the situation as best I can. The fact is I take no pleasure in discipline, but it is something that has to be done.

There is an exception to this and it is clear violation to safety standards or policy. There is a zero tolerance on this. In the past there was one example of a guy that was refusing to wear a disposable suit while mixing chemicals and a couple of other things safety related discrepancies. I should have sent him packing right there. The guy ended up playing some game about he was hurt a few days later. If I had acted, then I could have prevented the entire situation. So months later I had a guy straight refuse to wear gloves and his attitude when asked to put his glove on was I don’t need to wear my effing gloves. Once I found out about it I spoke to the guy, made sure I had the right guy and sent a clear message with a one way ticket to the beach. It was the right thing to do, but it could have been handled even better and I talked to the people that reported it to me on how we should deal with these types of situations in the future. What could have happened is the guy is sent to my office and I could have counseled the guy right then and sent him back to work. Under the circumstances I had no other alternatives.

With the right attitude on a persons part anything is possible.

^ That’s a very good post Capt. Lee, I remember your previous post with regards to having difficulties with company with a drug user.

With regards to the firing, many cases are grey areas and with skill can be turned around, Your point about putting it back on the employee is a very good one.

In some cases however it is obvious that the person has to go, drinking or as you point out repeated violations of safety policy. In these cases I go strictly by the book with witnessed and signed written warnings and I have had very little blow back.

I have the disadvantage of sailing foreign and not having a regular schedule so the cost of flying replacements is a very significant factor. We try to hang on to all but the very worse till we hit the States if we can.

[QUOTE=Capt. Lee;101037] . . . . We often have very little control over who is sent to fill a position and most of the time you have to make do with what you have. Having the developmental skills to motivate people to achieve things that themselves or others may not think possible. That is key. What you can achieve as a team is much more than any individual can on his own. With support, training and leadership everything is possible. I have taken someone that I was told just could not do a particular task and in the end they were masters at it. I wish someone would do that to me. I have a hard time accepting that an individual is not capable of something.

There were some good points brought up later that I thought were great. . . . . [/QUOTE]

That is a good point that sometimes one is better off keeping someone who’s limitations are known, rather then getting a replacement who’s limitations are unknown, and perhaps worse.

Your make an other point which most managers are very reluctant to accept: When an employee appears qualified and is hired for the job, but then fails, the cause is most often the failure of his supervisor to develop and manage him properly.

Anyone can churn through a lot of people. A very good manager takes the imperfect human capital that he is given, and then figures out how to build an effective team. Unfortunately, that’s much easier said than done.

Crew members can be either assets or liabilities. If someone has the ability, skill and time to turn a crew member from a liability to a asset that’s the way to go.

Meanwhile you can compensate by having a stronger crew member supervise the weaker one. However when the gear starts snapping around you are not only short the one crew, you lose a little more as a bit of the attention of the second crew member is needed to keep the first out of trouble.

Discipline is one of the more unpleasant tasks a captain has to do and I don’t know anyone who enjoys it.

My top priority is the safety of the vessel and the best long-term way to do that is is to build a good team with as deep a bench as you can. However sometimes in the short term it means having someone leave that boat. If that’s the case I try to it as quickly and as painlessly for everyone as I can. I also make sure that dot the i’s and cross the t’s. If you don’t it could come back to haunt you.

Can anyone who has a current Union contract share what the company contributions are per day/ per man for all the benefits? Health insurance, Life Insurance, Vacation, Pension, political activities, ETC? And, How much are dues, and initiation? I am trying to get an idea what the different Unions cost. Not necessarily which is best, Just how much each costs out of the pay package. We often talk about pay on here. How about the EXPENSE of a job!?

And how many Unions enforce rotary shipping, versus the ‘Once a berth is yours, it’s yours till you either quit or get fired.’

I work inland and my union is the MM&P. My employer pays 1248.00 a month for healthcare,6%+ a 50% matching up to 2% for the 401K. 8 holidays & 22 vacation days after 18 years. My union dues are $85.00 a month.