Forum Policy - So why can't we discuss politics anyway?

Relax fellows, I could start a thread or introduce you to my dear Asian-American nieces who prefer free health care, college loans paid off, and rent relief. Both are gainfully employed and have never been challenged other than in the classroom which they and their folks borrowed money in good faith and don’t wan’t to pay back. Niether of which has served in the National Guard or any service for that matter, and complain about having to get virus shots. Well ladies, I still love you, get the sickness instead. This is America, you have a choice, that many others don’t. They are highly intelligent, and book smart. Wish that translated to a hotly debated subject on this site,Common Sense.

There is a difference between civil discussion, and simply stirring up shit. Some here prefer one over the other.

It was a great suggestion by a few…make a category dedicated to political discussion… that way if someone accidentally stumbles upon it and gets offended by the rhetoric, its their own doing.

You can’t offend me (annoy me yes, but offend no). A separate thread won’t solve the underlying complaint.

However, if it were no holds barred, I might be ready to actually let fly an opinion or two :sunglasses:

BTW, is there an emoji that expresses the concept that a poster is irony impaired?

I did. In light of the NG being called in overwhelming numbers, what does it do to people when they see it in pictures and media reports? Does it inspire unanimity or division? It shows a Capitol clamming up, not remaining open because it’s a great democracy, despite the issues.

You missed the “if you want to talk about something else, start your own thread” part

You are literally the reason we don’t shouldn’t have political threads. Non-Mariners (as described in your own bio) coming on to the board to talk politics.

No worries. To be fair, I did use forum policy as a framing device.

There are only 2 ways to describe this…argument? Neither of which are flattering. So choose one or mix and match.

Regarding the Guardsman in D.C., in case you missed the news, there was an armed insurrection at the U.S. Capitol, orchestrated by radicalized right-wing malcontents, and egged on by the sitting POTUS. How does it look? It looks like an insurrection has been quelled, and steps have been taken to maintain peace and order.

Ok, so wrt the link in the OP, I started at the beginning, it seemed a little tedious, seems like ideas that should be familiar with anyone paying attention. Be quicker if a reference was used, for example I see a section that seems to be based on Daniel Kahneman’ work but he’s not mentioned (I skimmed it so maybe I missed it).

But starting at the end it seems better. For example he mentions Richard Rorty, that saves a lot of time trying to figure out what point is being made.

I did mention it in the OP:

…but my post is necessarily a bit of a mess, since I tried to tackle a much too big subject without straying into TL;DR territory, which evidently happened anyway. The piece would have been a lot easier to read if it used established terminology, but it doesn’t seem to be written for people who care about these things, so much as for people who never really thought about their mental processes before.

The “thinking ladder” and division of the Higher and Primitive minds is also a gross simplification that I found distracting throughout. However, it is necessary if you want to broach the subject to a wider audience, which is clearly needed.

I think it’s a commendable if over ambitious initiative. It seems obvious that given our current trajectory, this material needs to make its way into the education system, in a packaging equivalent to The Story of Us.

NG is just what it is ,it represents,our nation.You may call them “Weekend Warriors” but they volunteer to protect our rights. Put in horrible positions and go to war on our country’s behalf. That they have to protect us against ourselves is beyond me… They are not drafted, they volunteer. Policemen are not drafted as well. A few idiots have made their life hell. My time on this earth grows shorter every day, but can’t comprehend or agree that these are not good people. Go live somewhere else if you see a better gig.

I don’t come here to talk about politics. Usually I stick to Scuttlebutt because it’s not necessarily talking about professional mariner issues. It’s a little difficult to talk about other things because the news are always hammering the same things, and since this is mostly a US focused website, it’s the US news that are more prominent.

I think I will start a thread at some point but it won’t be about politics, necessarily. Maybe about the price of fish in the supermarket, used to be more fishmongers, tilapia sucks, regenerative agriculture, etc.

The insurrection didn’t seem half as bad as I saw it on tv. I’ve been to rock concerts with a bigger death toll and destruction. In fact, they were very polite and nobody left faeces in the politicians offices.
What makes Trump not simply concede and accept the term is over? When that answer is more than simple personality characterizations, then there’s a will to understand in order to avoid the same happening when Biden’s term is over.
This is the most powerful Commander-in-Chief in the world, nuclear arsenals and superpowerful Navy and the rest.
It’s not just about why we can’t talk politics. Why can’t we make an effort to understand?

Seriously. You should never feed me straight lines. I’m about to pull out a movie quote from “The Hangover”. 50 points to the first correct answer. 100 points if it’s a mod.

I didn’t watch the movie.

I understand completely. The problem is, everyone’s perception of reality, and what IS and ISN’T is different and far from consistent. Life is too short to sit here arguing about it.

Winner winner chicken dinner! And the aforementioned points.

This graphic from Pew Research says a lot about the depth of the divide:

pewgraph

It’s remarkable that people’s perception of reality differs so greatly based on which political cult they subscribe to. While there is no proof of causality, I nonetheless find it pretty intuitive.

Political cults come from noncritical thinking or an ulterior motive to gain control of a group for either ego purposes or as a means to achieve the goals of the leader of the cult. Hitler and the Nazis along with Stalin could have accomplished much more had they been born 50 years later with internet availability.
Jonestown is an example of a pre-internet cult. 918 people, including children died by committing suicide voluntarily or being killed on the order of Jim Jones. This was done before the advent of the internet and cable news that employed no fact checking of what they broadcast. Cults have a much more effective breeding ground now. The best hope is Darwinism. Like the people who refuse to wear masks in the midst of pandemic, perhaps they’ll die off due to being stupid.

Politics come up a lot just based on the constant inputs and triggers from news fighting for our attention. Just walking past a news stand is enough to make you stop and read all the magazine covers. We’ll never know the data they crunch and psychology they employ so that we feel the need to pick up that magazine, buy it, and be outraged for weeks.

Also, Youtube and every search engine I have tried is shoving “news” into my results. Trying to watch the Hand Tool Rescue channel? How 'bout these videos with obvious political undertones?! I looked up a dead novelist the other day on Duckduckgo which brought up current stories about Washington DC.