The old Black and White houses didn’t have AC and didn’t need it.
I know. We rented one in Alexandra Park. Stayed there from 1975-80:
Reminiscing about a time about a time when Singaporeans largely lived in Kampongs, segregated by origin, race and Chinese dialect groups, here is a link to a lengthy article about the way it was:
For those who have the time and are interested in the old days, here are more links: Read the history of Singapore’s public housing in From Villages to Flats (Part 2) – Public Housing in Singapore, and shophouses in From Villages to Flats (Part 3) – Traditional Shophouses.
Hard to believe that this was Singapore not that long ago, especially for those who have only been there and seen the Singapore of today.
Not so difficult for me, who lived there at the time of the great change of Singapore, from a newly independent colony to a modern metropolis.
PS: Although I stayed in bungalows and flat, I visited many of the Kampongs shown at the time.
Singapore, Inner Roads Anchorage in the good old days, ca. late 1960s, early 70s:
Photo: Forman Harrison
PS: Can’t see my ship in the picture, but recognise several of them from that time:
Used to anchor at Inner Roads around that time. (1971-72)
Pilots didn’t take ships in or out of there, you were all on your own. Could be a bit chaotic, especially when the tide turned. (Light ships turned first, loaded ships later)
That’s a nice ship. I’d bet she was easy to maneuver in and around chaos.
they do now
Yes AC is something we have got used too. Woodlands was once inside the Naval Base and the junior officer’s accommodation at HMS Terror was on an elevated bit of land with half height bat wing doors ( like those in a Western Saloon) both sides, high ceilings, a ceiling fan and mosquito nets over the bed. With a pretty constant breeze through the room it was OK. If the AC broke down or we didn’t have it like on one of our cruisers it was a different story.
Pretty similar to one of my old vessels. Originally under the French flag running citrus fruit from Florida. Starred briefly in the film The French Connection. Fully refrigerated with two tweendecks and a lower hold. She was not suitable for the trade she was in in the Pacific but we all enjoyed our time on board.
She looks a bit newer than “Jo-Tor” (ex Tor) blt. 1954, but fairly similar.
“Tor” had two reefer holds, with a long dry cargo hold amidships. Built for the trade between Scandinavia and UK, with Danish bacon as one of main items carried to UK.
An article in Straits Times 11 years ago, remenisening about the trauma that was felt 50 years earlier, at Singapore’s forced separation after only two years as part of Malaysia:
Here is Straits Times’ frontpage 10th Aug. 1965:
PS: Now, 61 years later, there is no contest about who came out best from the traumatic separation.
![]()
Gov finally added deposit system to some items where it was easy to do.
Why wasnt this done decades ago?
Problem is its illegal to rummage and remove items from bins.
Gov havnt addressed the tons of plastic that comes out of food courts every day which is most of the littering
The BCRS program and reverse vending machines are new to Singapore, started only this March - April:
It will take a while before the system will be fully functional and the population gets the hang of it. The same applied when the “Keep Singapore Clean Campaign” started(1968):
https://www.nlb.gov.sg/main/article-detail?cmsuuid=b2c2c063-431a-4aa3-8c8d-02dc3b2a117d
In Norway a similar scheme has been in place since 1902, then with bottles only. The present system, where aluminium cans and plastic bottles are part of the scheme, has been around since sometime in the 1970s:
Source: https://infinitum.no/en/
PS: Now bottles are no longer part of the system, but recycled through the common waste separation system.
Tomra has supplied revers vending machines since 1972:
One of my favourite places in Singapore used to be Tiong Bahru, especially the market and food centre:
Have had many good meals there, both in the old and new market. The wet market was our regular place for fresh produce and more. Good memories, especially when going there with my Mother-in-law. She loved to bargain and all the regular stall holders knew her.
Lew Kuan Yew as I remember him:
a system I never thought fair as locals get penalised due to wealthy foreigners
But it does extract huge money from the population.
Follow
WHOSE NEEDS COUNT MORE?
A Category A COE now costs $139,001. That is the record price set on 4 November and that is just for the piece of paper. It does not include the car.
So when a working mother of three young children says a car would change her life, who can laugh at her? Every morning she has to drop one child at nursery, another at primary school and her toddler at her parents’ home, before she starts work. A car is not a luxury for her. It is a need. Anyone who has done the morning school run with three small children knows exactly what she means.
But knowing her need is real does not mean Ravi Philemon’s answer is right.
In a Facebook video this week, Ravi Philemon said the COE system favours wealthy buyers over working families. He has a 22-page plan, called a Progressive Mobility Framework, which he has given to the Land Transport Authority – We Keep Your World Moving. Under his plan, people with what he calls essential mobility needs would get protected access to COEs. Working families would get help to afford their first modest car. People who can afford more cars would pay more for them. His party has also promised free public transport for everyone.
He said about one in five new Category A and B COEs went to individuals from households that already held at least two COEs. In September 2025, about 20,000 HDB households owned at least two cars, compared with 46,000 in private properties. Those figures come from Transport Minister Jeffrey Siow (萧振祥)in Parliament.
To be fair to him, he did not say every household with more than one car is rich. But then he builds his whole case on the opposite idea. If not every multi-car household is rich, how does owning two cars prove the system is unfair? These are ordinary families and a second car is often a practical choice, not a sign of excess wealth. So how can it be the proof that the system is rigged? It cannot and his own numbers go against his own argument.
Here is the question he never answers. Who decides whose need counts more?
Is it the working mother with three young children? Or the caregiver looking after an elderly parent who cannot walk far? Or the person with a disability who cannot manage a crowded bus? Or the shift worker who finishes at 2am when the trains have stopped? All of them have a real need but there are only so many COEs to go around. Someone has to rank them.
So who decides? Who decides that three young children count for more than an elderly parent, or that a disability counts for more than a night shift? Who updates it when the children grow up or the family’s income changes? Who hears the appeal when a family is told no? Who gets blamed for favouritism when one family gets a COE and their neighbour does not?
Ravi Philemon said working out who qualifies could be challenging. Challenging? That is the whole problem!
A list that decides who gets a car and who does not, is a list that will divide Singaporeans. Every family left off it will feel the Government has said their need does not matter. Is that the Singapore he wants? A country where neighbours argue over whose life is harder?
His plan does not even say how it would work. Protected access sounds generous but how many COEs would be set aside? Who gets in and what counts as essential? He has 22 pages and yet he still does not tell us. A protected access means a smaller access for everyone else, including the very working families he says he is speaking for.
Worst of all, his plan does nothing for the mother of three herself. Protected access is not free access. A COE at $139,001 is still $139,001. She would still have to buy the car, pay for insurance and keep it running. What he offers her is a place in a queue for something she still cannot afford.
The transport grant for larger families that Minister Jeffrey Siow spoke about is aimed at the real problem she faces every morning. A queue for a COE she cannot pay for is not help.
His party even promises free public transport for everyone and at the same time he wants a special protected queue for cars. If public transport were free and good enough, why would he still need a special car queue? He cannot have it both ways.
An analogy. A school canteen has ten plates of chicken rice and a hundred hungry students. Giving the plates to whoever needs it most sounds kind, until you have to decide who is more hungry. The boy who skipped breakfast? The girl who has CCA after school? The teacher on duty?
Someone has to play judge and every student who loses will say it was unfair. That is what Ravi Philemon is asking a civil servant to decide every day.
This is not the first time someone has tried this. In September 2025, Workers’ Party MP Jamus Lim proposed a needs-based COE system, with discounts for families with more children and for caregivers. The Government’s answer was that it is subjective, divisive and benefits too few people. I have rubbished the idea before as well. Jamus Lim could not explain how to rank one family’s need against another’s fairly. Ravi Philemon cannot either. Same impractical idea.
Meanwhile, the Government is doing the practical thing. In Parliament on 3 November, Minister Siow said most people who responded backed merging Categories A and B, with a feebate system. A mass-market car could get a rebate of up to $15,000, while a luxury car could face a surcharge of up to $15,000. And the transport grant for larger families is being studied too, for families generally, including those who do not own cars.
That is the difference. One side is working on improving the system with a rebate that helps the mass-market buyer and a grant that helps the larger family whether or not they own a car.
The other side wants to throw out the whole way COEs are allocated and replace it with a list of who needs a car most, without saying who writes the list or who answers for it when it goes wrong.
The working mother needs a system that is fair to her and fair to the caregiver, the disabled person and the night-shift worker as well. A needs-based idea cannot do that because it asks a civil servant to decide whose life is harder, and no civil servant can do that fairly.
Land is scarce, cars are scarce and no government can give every family a car. What a government can do is make the system as fair as it can be, without dividing us into the deserving and the undeserving.
Ravi Philemon’s and Jamus Lim’s same plan would do the opposite.
Populist idea, impractical execution.
PS
The gov gets as many cars on the road as it can as its a major source of income.
one way SG inc makes money
That was transfer pricing of Australian sales so very little paid there although over $10 billion of sales.



