Manslaughter Trial Begins for Captain of Solong Involved in Fiery Collision

He could not see / detect the vessel by all available means including visual early enough as per previous articles.

And yet the Little spittle asked him if Mutin could sea the huge anchor of Stena or may be the chain of the anchor .

And according to cretin Little by not seeing this important items Mutin could not determine if Stena was or was not at anchor. And fellow Mutin was supposed to detect this important details in given visibility and state of daylight. Interesting .

Last time I checked such determination of condition can be made by seeing black ball during day light or anchor lights during night time not to mention other lights. I will skip the other methods for a while .

quote:

Motin was questioned why he had failed to spot the “massive anchor” that was coming out of the Stena Immaculate and if he had seen it.

Motin replied he did not remember and could not recall if he had seen an anchor chain. He argued it may have been hidden by a silhouette or could have been on the other side of the vessel.
end quote

Now some blah blah about BWNAS

BNWAS – Bridge Navigational Watch Alarm System
Regs:
IMO Resolution MSC.128(75) “Performance Standards for Bridge Navigational Watch Alarm System BNWAS”
IMO A.694(17)
IMO MSC.282(86)
SOLAS 74 Regulation V/19
IEC 61162
IEC 60945
IEC 62288
IEC 62616:2010

BNWAS Bridge Navigational Watch Alarm System main objective is to monitor the activity in Wheelhouse and identify any disability of operator which could cause marine accidents.

In particular BNWAS monitors the awareness of Officer of the Watch (OOW) and automatically alerts the Master or another qualified OOW if for any reason the OOW becomes incapable of performing the OOW’s duties. Consequently a sequence of warning, indications and alarms alert first the OOW and if he is not responding then alert the Master or another qualified OOW.

Additional the BNWAS may provide the OOW with a means of performing Emergency Calling for immediate assistance if it is demanded.

It is important to be noted that the BNWAS should be operational whenever the Ship’s Heading or Track Control System is engaged and generates valid NMEA 0183 Signal according to IEC 61162, unless inhibited by the Master.

A ship’s Master can inhibit the operation of the Bridge Navigational Watch Alarm System (BNWAS), but this action is restricted by regulatory standards andsafety management system..!!!

According to IMO Resolution MSC.128(75) and related performance standards (IEC 62616), the BNWAS should be operational whenever the ship’s heading or track control system is engaged, “unless inhibited by the Master”.

Key points regarding this capability:

Controlled Use:
While the Master has the authority to inhibit the system (e.g., in specific navigational situations or to prevent nuisance alarms in port), the operating mode and the duration of the dormant period must remain under the control of the Master, often requiring a key or password.

Safety Management Systems (SMS): Company policies and the Master’s standing orders should explicitly define when the system can be inhibited, ensuring it is not disabled unnecessarily.

Automatic Mode Inconsistency:

While some systems have an “Automatic” mode that inhibits the system when the autopilot is off, this is considered unsuitable for compliance with

SOLAS Regulation V/19.2.2.3, which requires the system to be active whenever the ship is underway at sea. ( rem: irrespective on the number of watch keeping personel on the bridge)====>>>STCW check is reuired.

Tamper-Proof Requirements:

While the Master can inhibit the system, the BNWAS must otherwise be tamper-proof to prevent unauthorized disabling by crew members.
In summary, the Master has the authority to inhibit the BNWAS, but they are responsible for its proper use in accordance with safety regulations and …company policy.

Alarm Sequence Stages

Dormant Period (3 to 12 minutes): The system is active but silent, requiring no input.
Visual Indication (0s): At the end of the dormant period, a flashing light appears on the bridge to prompt a reset.

First Stage Audible Alarm (15s after Visual): If not reset, a buzzer sounds on the bridge to alert the Officer of the Watch (OOW).

Second Stage Remote Alarm (15s after First Stage): If the OOW does not respond, an alarm sounds in the Master’s and/or Backup Officer’s cabin.

Third Stage Remote Alarm (90s–3 min after Second Stage): If still not reset, a, loud, distinct alarm sounds in authorized crew member locations (e.g., mess room, cabins). = GENERAL ALARM.

No way to be brief on this topic . No effing way .

Cheers

1 Like

After the air asia airbus 8501 crash where the idiot pilot killed them all ( switch off the flight computers to reboot them) they finally said although many years of experience but not very competent

There is an Egiptian saying regarding long , long experiences :wink:

a piece of wood may drift a 100 years in the river Nile and never become a crocodille

2 Likes

After your comment I checked a few times today. It seems everybody chooses that coastal passage from Forth ports to Rotterdam. How bizarre!

1 Like

What a line!?
North Sea captain ‘only thing not working’ before fatal ship crash - BBC News
“There were no mechanical or electronic difficulties on the Solong. The rudder was working. The only thing that was not working on the 10th March 2025 was the man in the dock.”

Some old video clips from Dr.Sal show that all last voyages of said cont. vessel were almost identical with some minor variations.

Added.
He could do much better if he said he was sleeping if he wanted to cover up his absence on the bridge.

The consistency of the Solong straight & unwavering AIS based track line as viewed from various videoclips including Dr.Sal suggests the vessel was in the track mode.

Sitting in the stb side chair one may find a little joystick . To switch from track mode to manual non-follow up mode , one needs to touch the joystick with left hand.

The positioning of this little thing and size varies depending on the equipment but all the systems from my experience looked similar like one on the attached photo .

The yellow arrow is for visualisation purposes only to show how this thing may look like.

My worry with this easily accesible little clit was that somebody may touch it inadvertantly , therefore i never allowed track mode in heavy traffic or congested waters.

Hence it is highly unlikely the gent claiming such a long experience on same vessel could get confused in any scenario irrespective if in track mode or auto pilot heading mode or any other available mode of steering.

Cant blame the prosecutor for coming to such condemning conclusions and uncovering the master’s sleeping mode

Jury’s out…
Ship captain awaits jury’s verdict in North Sea tanker crash trial - BBC News

1 Like

North Sea ship captain guilty of US tanker crash death North Sea ship captain guilty of US tanker crash death

Guilty as charged

Added late pm.

“…unanimous guilty verdict…”
Once he has been sentenced, let the next round of suits (underwriter wars) begin.
And maybe we’ll eventually get a final MAIB report!
Hope it all helps the widow.

Guilty as !@#$. Not a suprise. Errors? Or just didn’t do anything.

Defense, He is guilty just not grossly guilty.

“…had turned off the system that required someone to press a button every 30 minutes…”

If memory serves, every ship I was in had the BNWAS set for 12 minutes. Most of my ABs had the presence of mind to prevent it from ever sounding.

1 Like

I do confirm 12 minures was the longest period but one can not treat the BBC art seriously about this shit show.

Without the real actual transcript which probably will not be available to public we do not really know who asked what and who said what.

Who were the ppl who decided guilty or not and how guilty. Cooks, taxi drivers
Captains of the merchant ships?

In my opinion he is guilty because he was either sleeping or absent from the bridge .

There is no effing way to behave like VEGETABLE itrespective of nationality unless completely drunk or deliberate action.

Anybody cared to count how many times " russian" was mentioned in these articmes. And this face of a pathological murderer .

The whole thing stinks and this court was a propaganda show.

The Brits still painfully remember the Balaclava masacre and have been living with revenge wish since then.

And since when they have been so dramatically concerned about life and fate of " the little brown people" ?

  • have U seen the Stena huge anchor, ?have u noticed the chain"?
  • if U have seen ,
  • the accident could be avoided .

What kind of crap and horse shit is that?

So MAIB is the only hope although I am not sure .

The Stena crew was interogated 1 or 1,5 day and left home quickly as there were medals and rewards waiting there for heroic actions.

And if the country can press Internation al courrs of justice and other european courts and threathen the court members/ judges with sanctions , then one can imagine easily how it can influence MAIB.

We will sanction you MAIB if U find anything depriving us of " heroic" actions and hero halo. . And we may consider 59% tarrifs on your reports and we need no laws as we have our own morale compass.

Sounds familiar??? Is it not?

Remember that this Old Bailey trial was only about a criminal case of “gross negligent manslaughter” in the death of a crewman. Nothing else.
It was not a case brought by MAIB, nor was this an MCGA maritime inquiry or proceeding in any way.
Obviously the legal teams had acces to raw info such as BNWASn’t, VDRs, videos, and all electronic records, etc as evidence for the case of manslaughter.
… key part in the trial is the April 2025 preliminary report from MAIB” is just a reference to that document’s use in evidence.
The good stuff is still to come.

1 Like

Captain jailed over North Sea tanker crash death - BBC News
Russian captain Vladimir Motin jailed for six years after deadly tanker collision | UK News | Sky News
led jurors on a “merry dance” in his evidence, which was an “exercise in inventive distraction” ; “truly, exceptionally bad negligence” ; …Motin’s account “extremely implausible”

Next?

1 Like

Appeal.

What was the thing with " he was going to meet his wife " or sth like that.?

The articles : typical British propaganda aiming to demonise the guy. Extra drama added by mixing pregnancy and similar shit to wind up not only the jury but reading public as well.

Despite his obvious negligence that led to collision and unfortunate death of " young father to be" somehow 13 remaining crew of Solong survived.

Do not see any inquiry why the victim was in the bosun store when all others were inside accomodation at the time of collision.

Was the Master aware of that, who instructed him to go there and for what. Was there whf contact between the solong bridge and the seafarer , if it was not then why.

What were the daily work schedules for all individuals as per MLC and surely as per SMS that would shed light if he was there in the course of duty or by his own violiton doing whatever.

Did he go forward due to his own violition w/ o informing the bridge. ?

With containers on deck from side to side the bridge personel can not see visually persons moving on deck and on all my ships one could go forward using under main deck passages all the way to the forcastle , bosun store , paint store , bow thruster room. .

Despite having VDR voice only a tiny part was revealed . Where are the voices , conversations on Solong bridge after collision.

I am not defending the guy as i suspect he was in the cabin or sleaping but this is a shit show .

I dropped here in some thread a book abt criminal issues on ships and surely from the text contained there it is evident the inquiry in this particular case was to say tje least perfunctory .

Who arranged a defense attorney for him ? State, His employer what I doubt , or his own what I doubt even more.

Was he allowed to consult with his peer , other company master and or anybody with some nautical experience ?or his only consultant , advisor was the legal eagle mentioned in the articles.?

Without answers to above I standy by my early qualification that it was a shitshow and farce.

Manslaughter case over, now the policeman’s perspective…
North Sea tanker crash: The deafening silence that implicated Solong captain - BBC News

BBC articles are behind a paywall for me:

Here’s the gcaptain article:

Extracts…
Detective Chief Superintendent Craig Nicholson.. summed it up: “I don’t believe Vladimir Motin’s ever given a truthful account about the events.”
As the case proceeded through the justice system and the Solong captain saw and heard all of the evidence in the months prior to court, the Humberside detective said a new account was “constructed to suit the evidence, but still makes very little sense”

“He couldn’t explain or wouldn’t explain what he was doing,”
“His account has changed throughout the course of the investigation and throughout the course of the criminal trial.”

Nicholson and the prosecution said they didn’t believe there was any mechanical failing to blame, and called the auto-pilot story “ludicrous”, but even if there was a steering fault Motin never contacted ship engineers to report an issue.

… and so on
Try Google news link, maybe? https://news.google.com/read/CBMiWkFVX3lxTE5hWEwycEM1RF95M08xWVVMd0s2U001RkVNVVFpUHJMeHB4enJiOEduZ2FKRHp5bjcwaGthLWVVSDJfUFZJVjZNdDJfS25lN0JPeWJtazJxaWViZw?hl=en-GB&gl=GB&ceid=GB%3Aen

1 Like

I am glad to agree with Chief Superintendent :wink: although he makes a statement having access to evidence while myself I am driven rather by my gut feeling.

The book I have mentioned previously is here and downloadable :

And this clip may be good reason for a whole new thread.

The laudatory speech of Dr.Sal about Stena crew made my jaw dropped with a loud bang probably heard in North Carolina .

Alision v/s collisiion comes back and should make @Kennebec_Captain
extatic or at least bring Him in NIrvana state of mind.

His( Dr.Sal) “competent” explanation describing the condition of anchored vessel as fixed object has made my jaw drop with even lauder bang. From my experience the only thing that is fixed( excluding dragging) is the anchor and the rest is moving to the tune of currents and winds . That is why the OOW at the begining of anchor watch establieshes on the chart ( ecdis or paper ) the RADIUS according to industry standards and practice.

Watching and listening to it i got the impression I see a new improved version of maritime goebbels propaganda show- and it is a compliment not an attempt to trash his excellency the Author. :joy:

Stena crew have missed a GREAT chance of getting another medal and laudation for saving the life of " soon to be father" by keeping an anchor watch according to industry standards .
Imagine : repeated 5 short blast could draw the victim from the forcastle on to main deck to check wtf is going on and what this noise is all about . Suspect that a quick glance around wolud cause him hightail in the oposite dirrection away from danger with warp speed .

Some appear to treat colregs in the same way as USA is treating UNCLOS.
When it is convinient we follow the rules , when it is not we have our own theory and our own moral compass.

Anchor watch and watch keeping: pls examine STCW( minimum standards)

Colregs: pls examine regs pertaining to ships at anchor( sounds , shapes, lights)

Sounds( mcy signals )

Comms: gmdss and use of VHSs for ship to ship ,ship to shore , comms in the areas under shore supervision both radar and comms.

The one comment I loved most :" we almost put the fire out but this " sonofabitch - my remark, seperated the vessels by kicking astern.

I see a myth is already growing . But a good tip, as having the engine in good order able to separate it means Motin( sounds like putin) could have used the same good working engine to execute a crash manouvere what he did not of course .

:light_bulb:
I found that extended post-sentencing i/v from DetSupt Nicholson via the BBC “Hull & East Yorkshire” article with VPN, at bbc.co.uk
This bbc.com version passes the wall, I think - North Sea tanker crash: The deafening silence that implicated Solong captain

1 Like