CII Ratings: How Much Control Does the Ship Actually Have?

How much control does a Master really have over a ship’s CII rating when so much depends on how the vessel is commercially employed?

We maintain the SEEMP, report fuel consumption and voyage data under IMO DCS, and eventually receive an annual CII grade. Meanwhile, cargo nominations, ballast voyages, waiting time and voyage schedules are often determined by commercial requirements.

The calculation uses the ship’s deadweight and distance travelled, regardless of how much cargo was actually transported. A ship can therefore receive a respectable CII rating without being particularly efficient in terms of emissions per cargo tonne-mile.

I understand why IMO adopted a standardized calculation. My concern is how that rating is being interpreted once it gets beyond regulatory compliance.

For those sailing or working ashore, are you seeing CII grades actually affect fixtures, vessel employment or charterparty discussions? And do the people assessing these ratings understand what the numbers represent?

I looked into the issue using a comparison of two hypothetical sister VLCCs:

1 Like