Chart Plot Chesapeake Approach

I’m working the sample exam chart plot (2/3m Unltd.) for the Ches Approach found here:

https://www.dco.uscg.mil/Portals/9/NMC/pdfs/examinations/q115_nav_problems_chart_12221TR.pdf

Question 1 establishes you 0530 position. This is then updated in question 2 for a 0540 position and course change. The 0540 position is stated as fact, i.e. YOU ARE HERE.

Question 5 then asks: At 0620, steering 219°pgc and turning for 14.5 knots, Chesapeake Light is bearing 191°pgc and Cape Charles Light is bearing 276°pgc. What is the set and drift between 0530 and 0620

The correct answer, per the CG, is determined from the 0530 position. But in what world do we ignore the fact that at 0540 we have an absolutely fixed position?

How is the correct solution not found by plotting the current derived from your course and distance made good between 0540, your last previous fix, and 0620 your current fix?

We all know how tricky these exams can be and one would think the CG expects to catch you forgetting the 0540 fix and course change using the 0530 position as the starting point for your CmG, especially knowing that these questions build upon previous ones. Plotting the set and drift from 0530 instead of 0540 fix would be navigational negligence. This has me absolutely fuming.

I know the question references 0530, but I cannot let the 0540 fix go on this one.

Does anyone have a different take?

The hyperlink you provided indicates a sample exam chart plot for 2026 which is for chart 13205TR and not 12221TR.

By looking on the cover page of the plot you are working on, you will find the year the sample chart plot was issued.

It should indicate somewhere between 2016 - 2026.

Ahhhh dang it, I had both sample tests up on my laptop and in my agitated state, copied the wrong one to the thread. The “correct” one is linked now.

Also, point of order to the fact that the course plotted on question 2 that yields the correct answer takes you on the shoal side of buoy R14 despite the question explicitly telling you to keep it to stbd. Am I going crazy here??

I am still missing the link that you are speaking about. got it

As mariners our mindset at sea is to consider everything cumulative.

However, in testing the USCG is developing a question on a specific task & skill set. You are correct that in question 2, we were give a 5:40 fix for the question on applying leeway.

Question 5 change the task to determine set and drift from 5:30 to 6:20. So we are told to ignore the NW breeze and its 6 degree leeway and provide a solution for a new task & skill set.

Now it is your turn to determine if I am crazy.

Respectfully consider this as a stand-alone task and skill leeway problem.

Where were experiencing a northwesterly breeze and producing a 6° leeway.

Working the solution: Remembering that the wind is identified as where it is coming from e.g., the NW. So we need to steer into the wind by 6 degrees base on the true course from our 05:40 position to .3 nm North of NCA buoy. What was the true course?

Now using th true course and applying the 6° to it we have solved for a true course to compensate for the wind. However, there are no answers reflecting true courses.

So we move to the next hurdle, which needs to be change to PGC using the Gyro Error provide as 2°W. This should produce the solution represented as answer D.

The theory is that a wind coming from the NW should move the vessel SE and thus pass buoy “14” down the starboard side.

Now it is your turn to tell me what I am missing and I am going crazy.

As far as I am concerned, the only way to work this problem would be to derive your CmG from 0620 back to 0540 at which point the leeway becomes irrelevant. These plots are supposed to simulate a sequential, real-world voyages. Assuming you have been steering 219 pgc since 0540 (not 0530 as this was given to you in question 2 as your position thus superseding the 0530 fix), you plot DR from 0540 to 0620, which gives you your set, as well as drift once you scale the 40 minutes up to an hour.

Plotting from 0540 to 0620 gives you the best time frame to determine set and drift since you do not have enough information to calculate S&D between 0530 to 0540, and given the short span of time involved here, I say would be acceptable.

The problem here is that the CG, notorious for throwing in little gotcha moments, would normally set the trap for you to neglect the 0540 position and start your CmG plot from 0530. This makes no sense. It would be a different matter if they told you explicitly to forget about the 0540 position and corresponding course change which they do not do.

My point is S&D from 0540 to 0620 should be more or less the same as S&D between 0530 to 0620 and in asking for the S&D between 0530 to 0620, the CG does not instruct you to ignore the 0540 position or course change.

Like recognizing common errors and having an answer choice that corresponds to someone making that error? Yes, they do that.

Absolutely, I agree with that idea. No issues there. But at the same time, the exams shouldn’t have the correct course on the danger side of a buoy that you are instructed to pass on the safe side.

If the test taker is expected to have exacting attention to detail, shouldn’t the team designing the exams be at or above the same standard? Otherwise a gulf of interpretation comes into play all of which works against the exam taker.

There were several bullshit questions. To my knowledge all were successfully challenged and removed from the exams in the new banks.

I have postponed continuing with my input regarding this conversation until now. My delay was to wait specifically for those mariners from the U.S. Maritime Academies to respond to your original post (op).

The basic issue is developing a testing mindset when taking a USCG Multiple-Choice examination. This mindset is best considering by referring one specific course requirement for senior year deck license-track program cadets at the various Maritime Academies.

The course is a Deck License Seminar which is 13-15 weeks long and is focused on passing the USCG deck licensing for 3rd Mate Unlimited Oceans which it is also a mandatory graduation requirement for their college degree. This creates a high pressure and stressful examination environment even with four years of maritime technology courses.

However, during this course the academy deck professors like the late Captain Joseph Murphy would and they currently discuss the formatting of USCG multiple-choice questions and highlight what to look for during various examination modules.

The License Seminar program has been previous discussed in various gCaptain threads. Also Mr. Cavo has put a response in others as well in this post as to the development process of USCG multiple-choice questions and answers. His comments have also provided insight as to how multiple-choice question examinations are structured at the National Maritime Center.

My observation is there are two styles of questions (1) the recall question and (2) a scenario- based question.

When an examination assessment team develops a task question, the focus is on two parts (1) the question a.k.a. the stem and (2) the four answer choices which one is correct and the other three well written distractors.

The question (stem) sets the immediate situational task being asked but can also have more information than is required, which I describe as a red flag or red herring issue.

General broad subject and topic tasking is provided when downloading a sample examination module. The subject of and topic for exam module Q115 Chart 12221TR 2025 were Piloting with Distance Off; Bearing Problems; Fix or Running Fix; Chart Navigation; Dead Reckoning; etc.

Subject and topic tasking for each of the 24 officer possible licenses is also found in 46 CFR 11.910 table 2. The problem is that specific sub-topic tasking categories or navigational methods like leeway problems; ETA; and set and drift are not identified until you work through some sample exams. This requires the mariner to self-categorize these sub-topics themselves when reviewing higher and lower exam modules found on the NMC Sample Exam website for 2026.

My final recommendation for this post is when taking a USCG examinations put on mental blinders so that you can block any outside noise and " only answer the specific question being asked."

To effectively achieve this, you will again need to look at 46 CFR 11.910 table 2 and identify all licenses that have similar subject and topic tasking. E.g. Distance Off is reflected on 19 out of 24 licenses. The five licenses not having distance off as part of their exam structure is the river endorsements.

Once you understand this method of getting additional questions then the next step is practice and practice on reading USCG questions using the method I am providing in my next post.

The following description is based on my past experience as a mariner taking USCG multiple-choice examinations, a Maritime Training Provider, a deck adult education instructor and tutor, a curriculum developer and validation (multiple-choice test) designer.

In my reading and deciphering the of question in your original post (op) focused on using a step-by-step method taught to me years ago while attending a curriculum design course which included dealing with multiple-choice examinations.

The course suggested a four-step approach.

(1) Look at the original question without looking at the answers and mentally asked “What is the question asking?”.
(2) Eliminating any additional information that did not seem part of the immediate situation and re-ask, “What is the question asking?”

My interpretation of what you provide in your op was the immediate tasking was to solve for initial course to steer between two positions given a NW wind with 6° leeway and gyro error issue.

My analysis was the red herring issue or long-term action was to pass Cape Charles Lighted Bell Buoy R"14" to starboard thus making it not part of the immediate problem.

(3) Without looking at the answers solve the problem.
The problem you presented allowed me to try and solve for the true course (215 ºT) between the two positions which was done mathematically by plane and mid-latitude sailing, and then graphically by doing a chart plot between the two positions to solve for the true course.

Next, I solved the 6º leeway problem by steering into the NW wind which gave me a course of 221 ºT which I then applied a gyro error 2ºW to predict a possible answer of 223 Pgc.

(4) Final step is to read all four answer and see if the predicted solution is one of the possible answers.

While I solved for Pgc two of the possible answers were stated as Psc which required an addition solution to eliminate all possible distractors and solve for one correct answer. The four answers were:
A. 217°psc
B. 231°psc
C. 211°pgc
D. 223°pgc
T V MN D C (+W/-E) Eliminated selection A and B as possible.
221º 10 º W 231º 2 º E 229 º Psc.

Calculated solution eliminates selection C and corresponds with selection D.

My reasoning to eliminate Buoy R"14" as a red herring issue or long-term action.

The scenario indicates that Cape Charles Lighted Bell Buoy R"14" is to pass on starboard side. However, the graphic plot between 05:40 and .3 North of buoy NCA course 215 ºT places Buoy R"14" at 05:40 fine on the port bow.

Mathematical and the graphicly plot places Buoy R"14" is at a distance of 10.2 miles. Based on a speed of 14.5 kts the vessel is 42 minutes away from the 05:40 position to the requirement of having buoy ”14” pass to starboard.

Therefore, I considered it a long term action and not part of the initial question.