The following description is based on my past experience as a mariner taking USCG multiple-choice examinations, a Maritime Training Provider, a deck adult education instructor and tutor, a curriculum developer and validation (multiple-choice test) designer.
In my reading and deciphering the of question in your original post (op) focused on using a step-by-step method taught to me years ago while attending a curriculum design course which included dealing with multiple-choice examinations.
The course suggested a four-step approach.
(1) Look at the original question without looking at the answers and mentally asked “What is the question asking?”.
(2) Eliminating any additional information that did not seem part of the immediate situation and re-ask, “What is the question asking?”
My interpretation of what you provide in your op was the immediate tasking was to solve for initial course to steer between two positions given a NW wind with 6° leeway and gyro error issue.
My analysis was the red herring issue or long-term action was to pass Cape Charles Lighted Bell Buoy R"14" to starboard thus making it not part of the immediate problem.
(3) Without looking at the answers solve the problem.
The problem you presented allowed me to try and solve for the true course (215 ºT) between the two positions which was done mathematically by plane and mid-latitude sailing, and then graphically by doing a chart plot between the two positions to solve for the true course.
Next, I solved the 6º leeway problem by steering into the NW wind which gave me a course of 221 ºT which I then applied a gyro error 2ºW to predict a possible answer of 223 Pgc.
(4) Final step is to read all four answer and see if the predicted solution is one of the possible answers.
While I solved for Pgc two of the possible answers were stated as Psc which required an addition solution to eliminate all possible distractors and solve for one correct answer. The four answers were:
A. 217°psc
B. 231°psc
C. 211°pgc
D. 223°pgc
T V MN D C (+W/-E) Eliminated selection A and B as possible.
221º 10 º W 231º 2 º E 229 º Psc.
Calculated solution eliminates selection C and corresponds with selection D.
My reasoning to eliminate Buoy R"14" as a red herring issue or long-term action.
The scenario indicates that Cape Charles Lighted Bell Buoy R"14" is to pass on starboard side. However, the graphic plot between 05:40 and .3 North of buoy NCA course 215 ºT places Buoy R"14" at 05:40 fine on the port bow.
Mathematical and the graphicly plot places Buoy R"14" is at a distance of 10.2 miles. Based on a speed of 14.5 kts the vessel is 42 minutes away from the 05:40 position to the requirement of having buoy ”14” pass to starboard.
Therefore, I considered it a long term action and not part of the initial question.