This comment is not aimed at any poster in particular. It’s meant to pleasantly inform fellow navigators who have, perhaps, done just a single maritime trade in their careers:
Do we all realize that a tug/tow can operate in very narrow waters, surrounded by granite, buffeted by tide gates with as much as ten knots of current, surrounded by kayaks and cruise ships traveling at close quarters, all watch long, day after day after day?
In those type waters, deep-sea vessels have a captain, a mate, a pilot and three ABs on watch. On a tug, or a fish tender, you have the mate or captain, and a single AB lookout who likely can’t tell the lights of a fishing boat from a Ford Fairlane at night. That’s the “bridge team”.
I’ve sailed deep-sea, all around the world, and I’ve sailed the IP most of my life. I can tell you the navigational changes of the IP would make most deep-sea mates lose their mud. I know this because I’ve gone through the Straits of Malacca, with fellow mates who confided in me they were about to lose their mud because of the perceived navigational difficulties, and the Straits of Malacca aren’t a pimple on the ass of the Jeannette Islands route of the IP. I’ve stood watch through the English Channel (had a pilot). Been through the Straits of Gibraltar in heavy traffic (yawn).
So imagine it’s 0400 on the IP, and you’re the mate on a tug, or a fish tender, and your "bridge team” is an AB who knows more about brain surgery than navigation, and you have a 1/2 mile to granite on your port side, and a 1/4 mile to granite on your starboard side, four knots of current, a passenger ship a mile ahead of you closing at 20 knots, and gillnets around you, and you lose the plotter. The half-asleep captain is on his way to the wheelhouse. What’s the plan to successfully avoid disaster in three minutes? Read a manual? Try to remember some steps? Rely on the sage advice of the AB? Open cabinets to flip breakers? Power up the spare whatever?
Or maybe, just maybe, in the three minutes you have to avert disaster, you can read a radar (hopefully parallel- indexed already), confirm your position in the channel by referring to the navlight ashore, look out the damned windows and actually pilot the damn boat. Is that too hard to fathom?
I think it is, for a lot of “navigators”. If all they’ve done in a career sailing deep-sea is handle their piece of the nav puzzle with five people in the wheelhouse every time they enter a harbor, maybe, just maybe they’re not qualified to judge what’s needed for the same degree of navigation done day-after-day by a “bridge team” of one.
Everybody says they can do that kind of navigation. I put them in a simulator and force them to do it. Then I find out some navigators struggle with it. And I don’t want my people struggling with simple piloting when the shit hits the fan. So we teach them more, and we put them in the simulator and make them do it again–harder this time. Until piloting with nothing but a radar and a light ashore is second nature to them. Then we yank the radar.
Navigation Rules They Never Teach in a MMA:
- No navigator ever said they were crappy at their job. And yet ships run aground all the time.
- When an officer runs a vessel aground, they get fired. Then they just get a job somewhere else. ( I had a captain run a vessel aground once. I fired him. He got another job as captain of a cruise ship. It ran aground. He got fired. He got a job at another cruise company as captain. He ran that ship hard aground on a sandbar…)
3)It’s the port captain who as to pick up the pieces with the USCG, the CCG, and the insurance companies. It’s the port captain who has to figure out how to stop the foolishness before it starts. You want to find out why boats aground? Ask the types who have to pick up the pieces. Not the types who go back out there are do it again.
No navigator every said he was crappy at his job…