HMNZS Manawanui on reef in Samoa

Hello
Very sad to see ships in accidents. Just went through the posts and have a question. Is the fire the consequence of the grounding or the other way around. Fire in the ER, loss of propulsion and she drifted to the reef? Thanks.

I think that is the question everybody is awaiting an answer to.

RE: lights on while abandoning … the E gen would’ve been on line.
she does have quite a list. As for the Cpt. being queer, I’d think they would avoid such assignments and just avoid the ‘glory’! Being in amongs such shore at night is certainly questionable although dp
can just hold till daytime ops resume.

As mentioned before, this from nzdf.mil.nz …
" * The Voyage Data Recorder (VDR) has been recovered and this will inform investigations being undertaken by a Court of Inquiry."

Well, according to this report she carried diesel fuel. Putting to rest the rumor I read here that she was carrying some sort of evil green fuel, or something? And it was all part of some woke conspiracy, or something? Can’t keep track of the nuttiness anymore.

Just diesel.

I think there was some confusion there in the initial report. Evidently she had a tank of Urea onboard. For what reason I don’t know.

Did they mean DEF?

DEF? Probably, it is well known by truck drivers and pickup truck owners that DEF is the devil’s brew made to reduce testosterone production.

If it did have a urea tank it was most likely to serve updated generators or other engines that meet IMO Tier III NOx emissions regulations. DEF completely lacks any hazmat quality other than the effect that its existence may impact the emotional stability of some rednecks.

Maybe pass on the idea to Jeff Foxworthy and team to do a number on DEF … :slight_smile:

I think Urea maybe used for post combustion treatment of the exhaust gas with a catalyst for NOx reduction … unlike DEF. Typically the silencer is replaced with a silencer lined with the catalyst and urea injected (load dependent) upstream.

Very likely this type:

DEF is a solution of about 2/3 water and 1/3 urea.

Sorry Bug, there is a difference between SOx and NOx. The system you linked is a sulfur oxide scrubber that allows the use of higher sulfur fuels.

DEF (diesel exhaust fluid) is a water/urea mixture that is injected into the exhaust stream to produce ammonia which reacts with NOx (nitrogen oxides) and a catalyst to convert NOx to nitrogen and water vapor. That system is called Selective Catalytic Reduction. Some systems also include a second catalyst to reduce ammonia slip.

The systems that offend diesel vehicle drivers also incorporate a DPF (diesel particulate filter) to reduce soot emissions.

From the Yara brochoure:

Sorry! I thought the DEF for vehicles was injected into the intake manifold. You learn something every day.
NOx is produced on diesel engines due to the peak temps during combustion. Plain water injection pre-combustion into the intake manifold reduces NOx. But may lead to other issues such as increased wear etc.
Interesting how the thinking (and technology) on emissions has evolved over the past 30 years or so. In the 90s it was NOx that could be controlled locally. SOx was dismissed as only decrease sulfur in fuel can provide relief for ‘acid rain’ etc. PM was 10 microns. CO2 was never discussed seriously. Next was PM 2.5 as a pollutant that needs to be addressed.
Fast forward NOx is kind of addressed with various technologies such as urea injection with SCR, low NOx injectors on gas turbines, etc. But seems to have been forgotten.
Next SOx. With the low sulfur reqt for fuels and scrubbers, this too seems to be resolved reasonably and not worth further discussion.
PM also seems to be under the radar with the high pressure injection with the common rail systems on marine as well as the auto industry … a lot less black smoke!
The latest is CO2 with the carbon capture initiatives, Not sure how this will progress.
I see shore side (Utilities, Microsoft, Amazon) are gearing up for small nuclear plants … personally I think there is a critical size above which the risk increases to unacceptable levels. Maybe the key is to identify this threshold … while I have no idea, if I have take a stab I would guess somewhere between 1-5 GW.

Correct Bugge. Early 2000s, I replaced one of the three DGs with a new MAN B&W DG on a class of vessels and also installed a SCR NOx reduction system (before the IMO mandate). The silencer/SCR was from your ‘friendly’ neighbor … Sweden. :slight_smile:

Yara is major producer and distributer of urea:


No wonder they got into SCR system to find another outlet for their main product,

Friendly since 2005 when we told them we didn’t want to share a King anylonger:
‘10,000 Cowardly Swedes Ran Through The Weeds, Chased By One Courageous Norwegian’ – Exploring the UK, Europe and Russia

PS> We imported our own King from friendly Denmark.

The latest technology engines still spew a great deal of particulates. Even when no smoke is visible the amount of soot is quite high. In the case of large yachts where a paint job can cost millions the direct costs of paint damage from hull cleaning alone is incredible.

Because the passive particulate filtration (DPFs) used on road vehicles really don’t work on marine generators that often work at low loads for long periods, an active system is required. In the interest of full disclosure, I invented, patented, and have manufactured and installed computer controlled active diesel particulate filter systems on very large yachts since 2013.

Wow! We have an inventor in our midst! Good show Steamer!

All marine engineers are inventors of one sort or another by necessity!