A Step Backwards for Maritime Domain Awareness (MDA)

On Jan 29th Rear Admiral (Select) Robert V. Hoppa, Director, National Maritime Intelligence Center, announced the renaming of the National Maritime Intelligence Center (NMIC) to the National Maritime Intelligence-Integration Office (NMIO). More important, and troubling, than the name change, is the consolidation of responsibilities. The new NMIO will assume the responsibilities of the National MDA Coordination Office (NMCO), which is currently charged with MDA information exchange within the unclassified sphere - NMCO was formerly known as the Office for Global Maritime Situational Awareness (OGMSA). This consolidation of efforts, both illogical and unwise, is a significant step backwards for national MDA.

Maritime Domain Awareness is built on information sharing, not on intelligence exchange or integration. If asked, most mariners will tell what they need is ‘information,’ not ‘intelligence’- noting the distinct differences between the two. Where as ‘intelligence’, by definition, is available to a select few, information moves freely, without restriction, among those that need and want it. As a former Chief of Naval Operations once stated, unclassified information exchange, and effective MDA, allows “the right people, to have the right information, at the right time…”.

Clearly, the efficient movement of maritime domain information should be the goal of national MDA. Yet, in an affront to unclassified information exchange, NMIO will work to coordinate all interagency MDA and information sharing - formerly the responsibility of the OGMSA/NMCO – behind the secure walls of in the Office of Naval Intelligence building in Suitland, MD. The OGMSA/NMCO, despite its failure as an interagency experiment (primarily due to budgetary limitations and the absence of interagency commitment), claimed several successes in enhancing national MDA by identifying interagency MDA capability gaps through the Interagency Solutions Analysis (IASA) and advancing the MSSIS program. These successes were a direct result of OGMSA/NMCO’s focus on information exchange in the [I]unclassified[/I] environment - thus enabling OGSMA/NMCO to build relationships and networks within the vast spectrum of maritime stakeholders ranging from interagency and commercial entities to international partners. Relationships and networks enable information exchange and are therefore proven necessities for effective MDA.

It remains to be seen how an intelligence organization (NMIO) will be able to facilitate the exchange of information between the numerous and varied members of the mariner community when only a fraction of these stakeholders have the ability to operate in a secure environment. Anyone who has operated with, or within, the walls of Suitland, knows that getting information to move outside those walls is a monumental, if not impossible task. It begs the question- how will an intelligence organization expand and enhance the networks critical to national MDA, if most of those networks are outside the IC community?

Ultimately, this move to create and rename a new MDA office is representative of the absence of alignment by the senior interagency leaders tasked with enhancing and coordination of national MDA efforts. From the restructuring of the OGMSA to be the NMCO, to the creation of the NMIO and subsequent dismantling of the NMCO, these national MDA coordination efforts have been characterized by good intentions rather than by focused efforts. However, these MDA endeavors have proven that although many obstacles exist to effective information exchange, information exchange is the essential foundation for enhancing both MDA and national security. Sadly, placing this new NMIO MDA office behind the walls of Suitland results in not just another potential obstacle to information exchange, but a significant step backwards for national MDA.

This surprises you?

We have been at “war” for 10 years and we can not even get the $2,000,000,000 TWIC cards to work let alone share information or, dare I say it, work together towards a common goal. I really hope you did not expect the powers that be with their large brains, “superior intelligence”, degrees and “experience in these matters” to come up with ANYTHING that is effective and makes us safer. They can’t even balance the checkbook and now they have to change the stationery along with everything else involved with a change like this.

I used to be outraged about the government, now I am just amused and ashamed at our leaders who are ultimately empowered by US. Boy were we asleep at the switch. Thankfully this bumbling bunch of bozos did not exist in the early 40’s when we had a REAL problem. Granted there was infighting and backbiting then but at least the job was accomplished.