USS Fitzgerald Collision: NTSB Investigation Report Highlights Navy Failures,

Well done! You can copy and paste. Go to the top of the class … except you neglected to read down the rule book a line or two below and so left out the ONLY means specified for determining a risk of collision. Let me know when you find it.

Just a reminder, navies train for war all the time and transmitting on radar, AIS, VHF, sonar, echo sounders and other means can at times tell the enemy not only that we are there, but positions, courses and speeds, the type of ships, force composition, and other things whilst detracting from our ability to passively detect the enemy doing any of those things.

Just to blow your mind, we also turn off navigation lights or rig deceptive lighting to look like something other than the reality. We even sneak up alongside merchant ships and try to blend into their radar echo.

If you want a Navy that can win wars, simply be aware we don’t always blindly play by these COLREG rules. That would be suicidal in operations so we must train for it in peace.

I utterly accept that when we do such things, we expect we have to keep out of your way and, as I’ve said previously on this thread, my experience was always that we went out of our way to avoid impeding your safe passage. But I’m talking about another navy

4 Likes