El Faro NTSB Document Release 13 Dec, 2016

From the transcript looks like the sequence may have been this:

  • Cargo breaks loose in #3 hold rupturing the fire main causing flooding in #3 hold.
  • Crew discovers flooding and an open scuttle. The scuttle is believed to be the source of the flooding The scuttle is closed
  • Crew takes measures to reduce the list, maneuvering to put wind on opposite side, pumping holds, counter-ballasting
  • Flooding continues until list reaches 15 degrees or more, the limit of the lube oil system and loss of lube oil pressure cause the propulsion to shut down.
  • Engine crew temporally restores propulsion
  • Final loss of propulsion
  • Flooding continues.